Yesterday the European Parliament voted in favour of establishing a ‘right to repair’ alongside a far reaching set of circular economy measures. MEPs were voting on a report on the Circular Economy Action Plan presented last year by the European Commission and overwhelmingly adopted sweeping measures to extend the life of products, increase access to spare parts and provide better information to consumers.

Another layer of support from the European Parliament

As an “own initiative report” it will not result directly in any new measures, but it gives a strong mandate to the European Commission to make ambitious proposals in a number of forthcoming legislative initiatives, including the Sustainable Products Initiative, the Circular Electronics Initiative and the Empowering the Consumer for the Green Transition, which are all expected to be tabled this year. 

A summary of the most relevant aspects of the report addressing repair is given below.

Once again, the European Parliament showed it supported consumers and the environment in the fight against throw-away products. Now the European Commission has a clear mandate to develop ambitious measures to prioritize repair and reuse in the spirit of a true circular economy

Chloé Mikolajczak, campaigner for the Right to Repair campaign

The Parliament’s clear position on repair raises the bar for policies expected to be published through the course of 2021. On the eve of the vote there were some efforts from conservatives in the EPP group to water down many of the paragraph’s concerning repair, such as the availability of spare parts or a repair label. This mimicked previous efforts from the EPP group to oppose repair legislation. These last minute changes however were not accepted by the majority of MEPs, who supported all of the measures in the text.

The amendments that saw the most resistance were on the mandatory minimum periods of time for the availability of spare parts closely followed by durability labelling and mandatory green procurement.

What’s in it for the Right to Repair?

The key aspects relevant for the Right to Repair campaign are:

  • Overall support for measures on waste prevention and repairability as well as establishing a new ‘right to repair
  • Repair and maintenance information: free access to repair and maintenance information, including software updates, and fair access for independent repairers
  • Spare parts: mandatory minimum periods of availability, and maximum delivery times for a range of product categories, 
  • Legal guarantee: extension of the legal guarantee and reversal of the burden of proof for products with a higher estimated lifetime, including direct producer liability
  • Repair and durability labelling: harmonised labelling on products, possible in the form of an index or repair score
  • Ban on planned obsolescence: a legislative measure to prevent practices which result in planned obsolescence
  • Calls on the Commission to make a legislative proposal to introduce a common charger policy for smartphones
  • Supports the Circular Electronics Initiative to address issues of obsolescence and repairability, upgradability and access to software
  • Calls for swift finalisation of existing eco-design work on electronics and ICT, i.e. for smartphones, tablets, computers, printers, and network equipment, by no later than 2021
  • Calls for an initiative on circular and sustainable digitalisation
  • Outlines the potential for repair and maintenance sectors, “local, grassroots and community repair initiatives, co-operatives and social enterprises” to create jobs

Join the Conversation

6 Comments

  1. we need to have the right to use generic, compatible spare parts… they are just too expensive today

  2. J’ai 4 imprimantes canon jet d’encre en panne et personne ne veut les réparer sous prétexte qu’elles ne sont pas chères et que le temps passé à trouver la panne éventuelle couterait plus cher qu’une neuve !!!

  3. Since brands just want profit, we need laws that allow us to use an expensive product we buy to its full potential. I mean replacing a 20€ battery on a 1000€ phone can give this phone a new life after 1 or 2 years of use. And unfortunately there is no options to choose from when buying a smartphone with highly rated camera that should somehow allow the owner to replace the battery (that is beforehand known to be a fast degrading component that can compromise the normal use of the system). My last 3 high end smartphones all were rendered unreliable after 2 years just because internal battery can’t handle high peak current anymore (so even though it shows 50% of state of charge, taking a video, or putting phone in hands free speaker voice would trigger an unexpected shutdown or restart).

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

More news

22 April 2021

On this new edition of Earth Day, aimed at raising awareness about the environment worldwide, let’s talk about the elements that can be found in all of our electronic devices yet most of us aren’t familiar with: rare earth minerals.

15 April 2021

Extending software updates, alongside making repair information and access to spare parts available and affordable is an essential aspect of a universal Right to Repair.

Campaign member Nesta explains why.